Document Analysis

Although this topic may be considered a bit more advanced, serious beginning genealogists would be so much further ahead if they knew this information starting out! When we run up against brick walls or just want to know more about a certain part of our ancestor's lives we need to revisit what we have already found. Often a thorough analysis of a document can give us more information or give us ideas about where to look for more information in other records.


The GPS or Genealogical Proof Standard guides us to properly collect sources, cite them, analyze them, resolve conflicts we might find in them, and then make accurate conclusions based on them. When done properly any documentation found thereafter will not disagree with or change the conclusion.

To begin, we need to focus our research into a single question. Then search for records that are relevant to that question. Next, we evaluate each document to determine:

Source Type: Original, Derivative, Authored
Information Type: Primary, Secondary, or Undetermined
Evidence Type: Direct, Indirect, or Negative

In class and on the PowerPoint, the different TYPES of evaluations were presented and discussed. Different documents were shown. To determine what the information on the document is truly saying, it is necessary to learn more about the specific record collection to which the document belongs.  Google, The FamilySearch Wiki,  Ancestry's Record Collection Descriptions, NARA, and Wikipedia can be useful resources in the learning about record collections and what information a document may contain and what it means.

Those attending the classes were quizzed after each document analysis to see if they could identify the Source Type, Information Types, and Evidence Types.

Those viewing the PowerPoint will see the answers and won't be able to check their knowledge. Sorry. Try to do it before you reach the answers.

I think the trickiest part is to remember that there may be lots of information, but EVIDENCE only pertains to the question.

Comments

  1. SusanAugust 4, 2019 at 6:37 PM

    Glad to have met you last week, Peggy! I love that you have a blog and will definitely be checking out your posts. There's so much to learn about genealogy :)

    Susan
    www.blogginboutbooks.com

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

MAY Family History Goal

Image
  For May I have updated the monthly family history goals to include QR Code handouts. The QR Code takes you to the monthly goal with explanations and links to optional fun activities. We hope this will appeal to young and old alike! This month we are celebrating Memorial Day! To see other goals with their helps go to the Consultant Resources  page. May QR Code Handout
Read more

The 10 Handcart Utah Pioneer Companies

Image
Summary of the 10 Handcart Companies 1856 Handcart Companies 1.   Edmund Ellsworth Company - Crossed the Atlantic on the ship “Enoch Train” .   Left Iowa City on 9 June with 274 individuals. 13 died. Arrived in the Salt Lake Valley 26 September.   Traveled with the Daniel D. McArthur Company. 2.   Daniel D. McArthur Company - 117 English who crossed the Atlantic on the ship “Enoch Train” plus 104 individuals from the ship “S. Curling” .   Left Iowa City on 11 June with 221 individuals. 7 died. Arrived in the Salt Lake Valley 26 September.   Traveled with the Edmund Ellsworth Company. 3.   Edward Bunker Company - Mostly Welsh who crossed the Atlantic on the “S. Curling” .   Left Iowa City on 28 June with 320 individuals.   Less than 7 died.   Arrived in the Salt Lake Valley October 2. 4.   James G. Willie Company - Mostly English with roughly 100 Scotch and 100 Scandinavians.   Crossed the Atlantic on t...
Read more

Quick, Simple, Fun, and Yet Instructive Family History Ideas

Image
I have dreamed for years of creating a simple plan for introducing the novice to family history concepts in short fun increments. I have provided my first plan for fun, simple, quick, and yet instructive activities that will introduce both young and old to FamilySearch . The goal is to introduce them to the essentials and then let the spirit of Elijah direct their family history path. These links will take you to the PDF version and the Word version of my one-year plan.  Use it as you please.  OVERALL YEAR LONG FAMILY HISTORY PLAN-PDF OVERALL YEAR LONG FAMILY HISTORY PLAN-Word Document I will share the step-by-step instructions on the Consultant Resources Blog Page  and update the 2022 Plan as FamilySearch changes throughout the year.
Read more